Pros, Cons, and Best Practices for On-the-Job Training

OEM - Training

Summary

The construction industry faces a growing skills gap and shifting workforce expectations. This quick read explores the evolving role of on-the-job training, covering its pros, cons, and best practices. It also shows how simulation technology enhances traditional training while boosting safety, consistency, and ROI.

From Labor Shortages to Skilled Operators: The Future of On-the-Job Training

The construction industry is at a crossroads.

Worksite technology is advancing faster than ever, and the tools used to train operators are evolving right alongside it. At the same time, an ongoing skills and labor shortage is making it increasingly difficult for companies to find qualified workers.

A survey by the Associated General Contractors (AGC) found that 92% of US construction firms struggle to hire qualified workers, and 42% are increasing training and professional development spending to meet the demand.

The good news? Operator training is evolving. Industry leaders are embracing innovative approaches that leverage technology to accelerate learning, improve safety, and reduce training costs. This renewed focus provides a practical solution, helping companies close skills gaps and develop operators who are confident, job-ready, and able to perform safely and efficiently.

In this post, we explore how innovative approaches like simulation technology complement traditional on-the-job training and share best practices to overcome common challenges, helping operators become safer, more confident, and job-ready.

The Advantages of On-The-Job Training

On-the-job (OJT) training is a time-honored practice across the construction industry, and for good reason: it works.

Research from the Association for Talent Development shows that 95% of organizations use on-the-job training, 75% rely on coaching from managers, and 68% incorporate both job shadowing and employee knowledge sharing.

The benefits of on-the-job training are numerous:

  • Real-world experience: Trainees gain firsthand exposure to the equipment, conditions, and challenges they’ll face daily.
  • Muscle memory: Repeated practice on live equipment helps operators develop the reflexes and confidence needed in the field (hands-on, field-like construction).
  • Cultural integration: Trainees quickly absorb a company’s values, safety culture, and teamwork expectations by working alongside other seasoned operators.
  • Skill relevance: Since trainees are learning in the actual work environment, the skills they acquire are directly applicable to their roles.

Overall, OJT builds competence, confidence, and connection, all of which are essential to workforce readiness.

The Disadvantages of On-The-Job Training

Learning by doing remains one of the most effective training methods, especially when paired with qualified guidance that reinforces safety and builds essential worksite communication skills.

However, many organizations are moving beyond a purely traditional on-the-job training model and instead combining hands-on experience with modern training technologies. While on-the-job training and live equipment use offer clear benefits, they also come with certain limitations, including:

  • Stress for everyone involved: Balancing learning with productivity can be challenging for both trainees and mentors.
  • Elevated safety risks: Working on live equipment introduces the potential for accidents or injuries.
  • Financial costs: Equipment misuse or damage, fuel inefficiencies, and lost productivity can add up.
  • Limited access to resources: Not all trainees get ample hands-on time with equipment or instructors, slowing skill development.
  • Variability in outcomes: Trainee progress depends on mentor engagement, experience, and adherence to company standards, which can lead to inconsistent skill development or unsafe habits.
  • Difficulty measuring progress: Traditional on-the-job training lacks standardized, objective ways to track trainee development.

Given the benefits and drawbacks of on-the-job training, what’s the best way forward?

On-The-Job-Training Best Practices

Several best practices can help reduce the challenges of on-the-job training. These include:

  • Identifying training objectives
  • Communicating goals and developing training plans
  • Monitoring progress throughout the learning process
  • Establishing regular touchpoints with trainees to ensure expectations are aligned
  • Demonstrating commitment to ongoing training and career development

Following these best practices helps set the foundation for a successful training program. However, even a full commitment to on-the-job training can benefit from a blended learning approach that leverages technology.

Leveraging Simulation Technology to Enhance On-The-Job Training

Adding a simulation component to training programs allows organizations to reap the full benefits of on-the-job training while addressing its limitations and reducing the impact of common challenges.

This approach allows trainees to:

  • Practice and make mistakes safely
  • Develop skills in a pressure-free environment
  • Improve cycle times without delaying work on real jobsites
  • Avoid causing damage and additional wear on machines
  • Train without burning fuel
  • Continue learning in any weather or when equipment access is limited
  • Learn faster in an environment that resonates with a new generation of workers

Simulation technology allows operators to begin their training in a safe, controlled environment before transitioning to real worksites. For training managers, it provides a clear way to calculate ROI: by tracking detailed performance data over time, they can highlight measurable improvements in efficiency, safety, and readiness.

For example, Conewago Enterprise, a leading Mid-Atlantic design-build contractor, reduced onsite crane training from six months to seven weeks and cut costs by over 60%, from $40,000 to $15,000 per operator. While traditional on-the-job training remains essential, simulation training builds safer, more confident, and job-ready operators faster.

Want to learn more about how simulation training can build a job-ready workforce? Check out our e-book: Remove Guesswork and Risk from the Operator Hiring Process.

You Might Also Like: